Customer Benefit Analysis

Customer Benefit Analysis

A customer benefit analysis helps to quantify one’s own market position. However, the probability that a customer will buy from us and not from the competition can already be reliably read from a qualitative analysis. This saves time and prevents spurious inaccuracies that distract from the essentials.

Customer benefit analysis is based on the empirically well-supported assumption that customers compare the price/performance ratio of the alternatives they are considering in their purchasing decisions.

Customer benefit analysis determines the cost/benefit ratio from the customer’s point of view. The “benefit” is all the advantages perceived by the customer that he expects from the purchase decision. The “cost” covers all the disadvantages the customer associates with the purchase (not the manufacturing costs of the product or service).

In this context, not only easily graspable, rational criteria such as engine power (benefit) or price (cost) are considered, but also more vague, emotional criteria such as brand image (benefit) or reputation risks (cost). The customer decides in favor of the alternative that has the best cost/benefit ratio from his perspective.

Customer Benefit Analyssis: Alternatives Map

Customer benefit analysis: Alternatives Map

Example “Ristorante da Noi”

It is first necessary to specify exactly which purchase decision is being modeled. In the example shown here, “Ristorante da Noi”, a new entrant to the market, analyzes how he is positioned when neighborhood residents decide not to spend the evening eating in front of the TV. Accordingly, the “Alternatives Map” contains not only other restaurants, but also non-industry alternatives that customers consider when making this type of decision. Inviting some friends to cook and eat together is a valid option in this “buying” decision. The “Ristorante da Noi” must take this into account in its planning.

It is recommended that a second customer benefit analysis be made for the “which restaurant are we going to tonight?” purchase decision. This would focus on the submarket of those customers who have already made the preliminary decision to visit a restaurant. This sharper focus, however, hides various possibilities for potential customers. Perhaps “da Noi” could grow easier in the large market of “home cooking” with a catering service than with a frontal attack on the restaurants “Toni’s Pizza” and “Zio Giovanni”?

Private and business customers tend to buy where the perceived benefit is large and the perceived cost is small – in the graphic with the restaurant example, this is the bottom right corner. The alternative that is farthest from the fair value line in the bottom right corner has the best cost/benefit ratio and thus the highest probability to win the customer. This means the best market position for the specific purchase decision. In the example, this is “Cooking yourself”. Zio Giovanni” has the worst market position. From the customer’s point of view, he delivers the same benefit as “cook at home” but is around three times more expensive.

The safest prognosis for the constellation of this example is therefore that the alternative “cook at home” will gain relative market share the fastest. Ristorante da Noi” and “Toni’s Pizza” can also hope for an increase in relative market share, but much slower than “cook yourself”. The choices in the top half of the chart have a below-average probability of acceptance and are therefore likely to lose relative market share.

Presumed Market Developments and Planning

Integrate Presumed Market Developments into Planning

Presumed Market Developments and Planning

The basic engine from the post “Early Warning and Planning” shows that order intake is the most important factor for sustainable success and has consequences for almost all planning and control areas. Market-related early warning means analyzing and assessing the factors influencing order intake in the medium and long term and their interdependencies. These factors include disposable income, the behavior of competitors and the interest of retailers in actually promoting the products and services they offer.

The most important factor in attracting new customers, however, is the customer benefits offered by the company’s own offerings compared with those of its competitors.

Presumed Market Developments and Planning
External influences on order intake

Analysis of customer benefit

To receive an order requires that a customer (or a group) decided to buy the offer. Thus it is the customer who decides about the relevant criteria and their respective weight according to his needs.

If you want to improve the planning and management of your organization and make it successful in the long term, you have to know from your offerings (products, services) how well they meet the criteria used by customers. The better the customer’s purchase-deciding criteria are met, the more the company sells. This knowledge can be gained through customer benefit analysis.

The purpose of a customer benefit analysis is to find out, which criteria future consumers apply when they decide for my offer or for another one. To do so, customers compare the benefits, performance and advantages (benefits) of a procurement option to its disadvantages, acquisition price, current expenditures in their application (cost). Then they rank the different opportunities to decide. The result is a cost-benefit-analysis for each examined option.

If such an analysis is consistently prepared from the buyer’s point of view it has the central advantage for salespeople, managers and controllers that it includes all aspects relevant to the buyer and also assesses the competitors. Thus it covers nearly all marketing aspects. The possible procurement variants are compared regarding:

cost benefit
cost benefit

If an organization can afford to outsource the preparation of a customer benefit analysis, there is a good chance that the main competitors will appear in the analysis and be fully assessed from the customer’s point of view. Our experience shows that even a less expensive analysis carried out by an organization’s own staff can yield significant insights. The prerequisite, however, is that the interviewees are repeatedly reminded to take the perspective of a potential customer.

In the book Customer Orientation in Innovation, Marketing, Sales and Leadership, Markus Orengo provides guidance on how to conduct a customer benefit analysis. He has also developed an Excel-based tool that provides step-by-step support for setting up the analysis and also presents the results graphically for decision-making purposes.

Overall market influences on order intake

Other factors of market activity, which a customer benefit analysis cannot depict, can become early warning information:

    1. Conditions for resellers (i.e. dealers, craftsmen, doctors, software importers)
    2. Sales and turnover development of competitors
    3. New products, which could harass the own portfolio
    4. International trade restrictions / tariffs / import or export bans
    5. Development of new international standards which could prevent the sale of own products
    6. Disposable income of the demanders / economic situation (can I afford it?).

Points 1. and 2. require the observation of the competition. However, the information usually comes late, as it is obtained by interviewing resellers or through publications. It is therefore important that the company’s own sales staff also use their customer contacts to find out about purchases made by their customers from competitors and to document the information afterwards in the internal reporting system (CRM system).

As markets become mature, mergers and acquisitions often occur as the large vendors try to increase their market share and thereby improve their cost position. Such events also have an early warning character. This is because they often occur in such a way that in mature markets, 5 – 6 groups worldwide hold 70-80% of the market shares and thus dictate the market rules (e.g. automobiles, personal computers, operating systems, cell phones). In such situations, the smaller companies often have to reinvent themselves and launch new products and applications to survive.

Information on mergers, sales trends, new technologies and products, trade barriers, and government regulations (items 3 – 6) provide important inputs for adjusting a company’s own policies and strategies. Decision makers must interpret the data and take it into account when revising plans.

One starting point for containing the effort and time required to obtain this kind of external data is it to subscribe for the services of a media monitoring agency that is individualized for the company’s own issues. This way of obtaining early warning data can also be used in research and development fields or for tracking disposable income.

Glossary

The glossary defines management control system terms used in this blog and explains how unclear definitions lead to incorrect results.

Activity-Based Costing

Activity-Based Costing (ABC) is an approach to costing that focuses on activities as the fundamental cost objects, then uses the cost of these activities as the basis for assigning costs to other cost objects such as products, services or customers.  In the Management Accounting System proposed here this cost charging should only happen based on the planned proportional costs of the serving cost centers. The managers of the receiving objects are neither responsible for the fixed costs nor for the variances in the serving cost centers.

Actual cost proof

Enables the cost center manager to access all documents that led to cost debits in a period.

Bill of materials

A specification of the quantities of raw materials, purchased parts and semi-finished products required to produce one unit or a released production order.

Charging internal services provided (ISP)

This occurs when the following prerequisites are fulfilled:
The issuing cost center must plan costs that are directly caused by its activity level,
The receiving cost center can decide for itself if it wants to consume the service or there is an automatic mechanism that with more units in the receiving cost center, more activity has to be performed by the performing cost center (for example, maintenance work required after every 1,000 operating hours).
In the best-case scenario, the receiving cost center can decide for itself whether it procures the service from internal or external contractors.

Check

A check is a necessary but not sufficient element of feedback-loops. The actual results of any activities are assessed and compared with the corresponding target values. This is followed by a variance analysis and the decision as to with which corrective actions the targeted situation can be restored.

Contribution Margin II or CM 2

Misleading term in multilevel and multidimensional contribution accounting. CM II is reported by various ERP vendors as the difference between net revenue and full product cost. Due to the allocations necessary to calculate the full product cost, this CM II is no longer a real CM. In the relevant literature, e.g., Kilger (1988, p.73) or Kilger, Pampel, Vikas, (2002, p.531), CM II does not occur with included fixed costs. We recommend using descriptive names for the levels after CM I, since other fixed costs are to be deducted from CM I in the product dimension than in the customer dimension.

Controller

Controllers provide management support to managers at all levels. They develop and implement all necessary instruments and systems that managers need for performance and value-based integrated planning and control (see the Controller’s Dictionary CWB, and the mission statement of the International Group of Controlling).

Controlling

Controlling is managers’ task (keep your business under control). With their instruments and advice, controllers enable managers at all levels to carry out controlling.

Cost allocation

“The assigning of indirect costs to the chosen cost object (Horngren, 1999)”. It makes sense to allocate costs directly dependent on the activity level of a serving cost center to other cost centers or product units, since these are proportional production costs. However, fixed cost center costs can never be correctly allocated to other cost centers or products due to a lack of a direct cause-and-effect-relationship. This is why fixed cost allocation does not occur in a truly decision-oriented management accounting system.

Cost of sales method

Under this method the net revenues for the period are compared with the product costs of the products sold during the period. The product costs of changes in inventories of semi-finished and finished goods are reported in inventories.

Cost position

A company has a better cost position than that of its competitors if its value-added costs per unit are lower. While it may not be possible to precisely calculate this figure, cost-cutting opportunities must be sought constantly and everywhere in the company in order to survive price competition and to maintain profitability.

Customer benefit

Ratio of the benefits that a customer expects from his purchase decision to the disadvantages he incurs with the purchase (his own application costs). Also known as the cost/benefit ratio.

Delivery reliability

Measure of the degree of compliance with agreed delivery dates. Delays are usually measured in days or hours. This key figure can be used for vendors, production items, warehouse receipts, and deliveries to customers.

Disburdening costs

Costs charged from one cost center to another or to orders (like with credit and debit accounts in financial accounting). This transfer of costs leads many cost center managers to believe that it is good if they can pass on their own costs (including those allocated) in full or even with a surplus to others.
From a business point of view, disburdening makes no sense. Costs are budgeted and incurred in the serving cost center and should be controlled there. The proportional costs of the services rendered are charged to the receiving cost centers or orders. The planned fixed costs and the spending variances remain in the origin cost center. From there, they are transferred by means of stepwise contribution accounting.

Effectivity

Effectivity means “Doing the right things”.

To become effective you need to fix objectives (which results do you want to achieve?) and then to define the key results that will be achieved when the objective is met.  See also OKR Objectives and Key Results.

Efficiency

Efficiency means “Doing things right”.

If you find a possibility to do a production step in shorter time, you become more efficient.

Flexible budget / Should-be costs 

The flexible budget is the planned cost adapted to the actual activity level of a cost center. Calculation formula: Planned fixed costs + (Actual activity / planned activity x proportional plan costs).
The flexible budget thus indicates what costs (in total) a cost center manager should have incurred at an actual activity level. In other words this figure represents the costs that “should have been”. This is the suitable yardstick for comparison with the actually incurred costs, as it aligns the plan to the actual performance.

Free samples

Samples of a company’s product distributed free, often as an introduction to potential customers. They are part of the costs of a sales order or of a customer agreement. Since inventory withdrawals are necessary for these, the proportional standard costs per unit are to be used for the evaluation.

Functional concepts

Medium-term plans to develop support functions needed to successfully support the achievement of strategic product/market objectives. Functional concepts (functional strategies) are always derived from product/ market strategies.

Functional diagram

Two-dimensional representation of tasks and the persons or organizational units involved in their fulfillment. The tasks are listed in the rows, the participants in the columns. The contribution of the position is entered in the resulting fields by means of an abbreviation.

Good unit or piece

Product unit that meets all qualitative specifications and can be placed in inventory.

Holistic

Integral, integrated, to look at something in its entirety.
An integrated performance management system must take a holistic view of a company’s activities, including all its dimensions, including changes in the current and future (partial) environments of the company.

Internal tasks

All work performed in the cost centers that is neither directly caused by the manufactured and sold products, nor requested by other cost centers according to their free will.

Key figure system

Mathematically or logically linked combinations of several key figures (absolute or relative numbers with a special meaningful value). Key figures can be derived from planned values or from actual data and serve as a yardstick to represent cause and effect of processes in a causal relationship (CWB, p. 140 f.).

Key Performance Indicators (KPI)

Quantifiable measurements that reflect the critical success factors of an organization. (IMA Management Accounting Glossary).

Machine-hour rate

A machine-hour rate is formed to charge the directly performance-related machine costs (energy, preventive maintenance, lubricants) as well as the performance-related personnel costs of the machine cost center to the products and orders.

Management control

An organized, integrated process and structure through which management attempts to achieve enterprise goals effectively and efficiently. It provides well-defined units of measurement and evaluation, measures actual performance, and emphasizes continuous comparisons of actual with planned or budgeted performance, and taking corrective action and forecasting. (IMA Management Accounting Glossary).

Management Control is the process by which managers at all hierarchical levels ensure that their strategic intentions are realized (see the definitions of R. Simons (in “Levers of Control”) and R. Anthony/V. Govindarajan (in “Management Control”).

Management Control System (MCS)

Consists of the instruments needed to practice management control. The instruments can be divided into three main groups: 1 Management accounting for operational planning and control, 2 Piloting information for planning and control of mid- to long-term internal developments, 3 Early warning information from outside the company to support decision taking for the future development within the changing environment (strategy).

Material quantity variance

The difference between the precalculated and actual quantity of a raw material or semi-finished good used to produce a given output, valued at standard proportional cost per unit.

Net proceeds

Gross selling price less all possible sales deduction items.

OKR

OKR or Objectives and Key Results is a further development of management by objectives. Intel and Google in particular achieved great success with the working group-related definition of objectives to be achieved and the regular measurement of the (financial) results achieved during the year.
Each team member is responsible to the team leader for achieving the results. This applies to content, deadlines, costs and revenue.

Plan

To intend, be determined, be willing, aim, have in mind, seek. “Planning” is understood here as a creative act that leads to the determination of the results to be achieved together with the allocation of necessary resources as well as the denomination of procedures needed. A plan also serves as a basis for comparing what has been achieved with what has been intended (feedback-loop).

Planned activity level

The product-related activity that a cost center is to perform in the planned year. It is derived from production planning. Planned activity level is specified with the reference factor unit (RFU) of the cost center that describes the cause of the costs (usually employee hour).

Production planning (Rough planning, Order planning)

Planning the quantities of each product to be produced for a year. For this purpose, the products must be broken down into their individual parts according to the bill of materials so that it can be seen how many units are to be produced per item. The capacity requirements per cost center are then calculated using the standard times in the work plans. Rough planning is intended to show whether the available production capacities will be sufficient to process the demanded program. The capacity requirements are then the planned activities of the individual cost centers.
Real production orders are created based on the current requirements. They contain the order specific BOM and the work plan. This information is used to reserve capacities in the cost centers (dispatching). The production order data is the technical basis of the preliminary costing of an order.

Purchase price variance

Occurs when the actual purchase price for a raw material or service differs from the planned (standard) price at the time of purchase. The variance should be reported so that internal consumers (production, cost centers, sales) can distinguish between the share of the variance due to market effects and the share due to their own variances (material and working time).

Rolling plans

If new orders are received with due dates, they have to be included in production planning for the next period. Cost center plans and item-related standard costs should not be changed in management during the year, as they contain the objectives to be achieved. The incorporation of new or unplanned influences happens in the precalculation of orders and in the forecast (for the target- and result-oriented area). A forecast is made based on the expectations of the forward-looking manager, not on the basis of projections.
In medium-term planning with a multi-year horizon, rolling plans are the norm, since the existing plans for subsequent years are drawn up based on the current results achieved and considering the changes that have occurred since the last plan adjustment.

Routing variance

This is the cost-consequence of a production run that was performed in other cost centers or on machines other than planned in the precalculation.

Sales deductions

Reductions of the price received from the customer which the company has to bear (e.g., bonuses, reimbursements, cash discounts) as well as cost elements to be borne by the company because of the contractual arrangement with the customer (e.g., non-invoiceable freight, transport insurance, transport damage).

Service level agreement (SLA)

An agreement or a point of intersection between a customer and the service provider for recurring services. The aim is to make the control possibilities transparent for the client by describing in detail the guaranteed performance characteristics, such as scope of services, reaction time and speed of processing. An important component here is the quality of service (service level).
Service providers can be external contractors, or one or more cost centers. The ordering party is the community of cost centers receiving the services. SLAs regulate quantities, qualities, deadlines and availabilities. Cost allocation to the receiving parties should not be part of an SLA, since the costs are to be controlled by the service provider.

Spending variance

The difference between “should-be costs” (i.e., flexible budget costs) and actual incurred costs. If the actual costs in a cost element are higher than the target costs, this results in a negative variance because the difference has a negative effect on the company. A positive variance shows the size of realized productivity improvement in a cost center.

Strategy

The way that an organization positions and distinguishes itself from its competitors. It is the basic business approach an organization follows to meet its goals. A strategy defines the product/market combinations to be reached and the future potentials for success to be built up in a measurable and verifiable form. A strategy is formulated for a Strategic Business Unit based on customer needs. This means that a corporation can follow several strategies at the same time. Strategy implementation always requires operational planning and its execution. To do so, changes in the functional areas are often a prerequisite. These are planned in the Functional concepts.

Sustainable

The ability of a company / system to continue to exist successfully despite changes in its surrounding environment.

Total cost method

A method for the presentation of an income statement which compares the net revenues of a period with the total costs/expenses incurred in the period, broken down by cost type. Since revenues refer to the quantity sold, but costs are incurred based on the quantity of goods produced, the change in the value of inventories must be shown to make the basis for reporting revenues and costs consistent.

Value-added

The difference between net sales and all purchased and consumed inputs (material, energy, all external services purchased against invoice or cash).

Variable costs

These correspond to proportional product costs. However, the term “variable” should not be used, since all too often the proportionality of the costs to the quantity produced is confused with the controllability of costs (CWB, p. 200).

Wage provision

Wage provisions must be booked if work has been performed but not yet settled and paid out to the employee (holiday pay, overtime, flextime). Such positions reduce the monthly result and must therefore be recorded.

Work plan

A description of the processes to be carried out during the manufacture of a product, indicating the cost center and the time allowed to carry out the individual tasks (similar to the preparation descriptions in a cooking recipe).

Working time variance

Occurs when the allowed (target) times according to the work plan are different from the actual services on the order.